Halo 3 vs. Metroid Prime 3

Which game has better:

Graphics

Storyline

Innovation

New Material

Controls

Gameplay

Sound/Music

Physics

AI

Sales

Hype

And just over all quality.

I’ve seen alot of debate and arguement about which game will be better, and I want to have it debated in this thread based on the factors that I listed above.

Metroid’s story is almost non-existant. It’s not that kind of game. Halo, the story is really really crappy.

Metroid has far better single player but Halo has a way better multiplayer and in most cases that wins.

the21gamer wrote:

ramunematt wrote: Did you hear me? I’m a bigger better pussy than you’ll ever be.

Wtf...

Well seeing that we’ve played neither I don’t think there is any possible way of telling. But I agree with the storyoline part. Metroid has never been about the story though if you do dig deep it’s quite intriguing. But same goes for Halo. Halo’s is very simplistic and not anything really to brag about.

But other than that I couldn’t assume on any part of this except that graphics and multiplayer will go to Halo 3 for obvious reasons.

spec related things go to halo. so, it gets graphics, sound, physics, and ai. i think prime 3 will probably win in the story department, but that will be a close and hard battle. its impossible to say seeing as neither of them are out. innovation has to go to mp:3, and new material could go either way. i think mp:3 has a shot at controls also, but it could go either way (early reviews are absolutely raving about the revised controls for it). don’t really know how to judge gameplay, especially seeing as neither game is out...halo 3 probably will have bigger sales and hype just because its halo, but i think mp:3 will have better quality overall.

just my two cents...