Wich is better eragon or harry potter?

Uninvited wrote:

Green_Ninja wrote: Eragon was a horrid book. There were so many things wrong with it, I can’t even begin to explain..

For one, a 15 yr old wrote it, and I was 15 when I read it. It was CLEARLY written by a child. So many problems, no detail, no creativity.. It was basically a bunch of books crammed together. Come on, dude.. Write an original, it’s exactly the same as all the other mainstream Fantasy out there.

Harry Potter was good as a child fantasy story.. When I was younger I loved it.. Now, though.. My taste has changed a bit.. I no longer crave a simple plot that always turns out the same in every book. I don’t like predictable. and I DEFIANTLY don’t like writing for money. Which is EXACTLY what JKR did after the 4th book. =/

So actually, both suck.

You are all to true with Eragon... but you forgot to mention that it was BORING!!!! I honestly fell asleep in the first 10 pages... the only reason people liked it was that there was a lot of hype, and that a 15 year old wrote a book! ooooh... look at me... i’m 15 and i can write a crappy book! yay!!! whatever, i even liked harry potter better than that... and i’m not a huge fan... i really only liked the last book...

Acuttally alot of people like it because all the blood and gore and violence.you have to read the prolouge.Also read up to the part where Eragon learns to sword fight and learn to use magic.

harry potter is my fav then eragon

“Sometimes i feel like a butterfly trapped inside a cocoon
wishing i could spread my wings and fly away”

i dont like nither.
i think they both suck

slipknot_666_ wrote: i dont like nither.
i think they both suck

learn not to revive threads old threads.Read the first 100 pages before you judge a book while you’re at it.

Ulquiorra Schiffer wrote: i think eragon is better cause its with more violence.And dont get me wrong ive read all 7 harry potter books they are my 3rd favorite sereis.but eragon is over all better

The inheritence trilogy opps my bad “Cycle” is a joke, the author can’t write good shit, Eragon was good, but the other books were painful to get throught and his constant descriptions of the bloody elf girl was pointless throughout the books, we get that the author wants sex with a real girl but gawd its annoying, and the twist in eldest were eragon is an elf is laughable (wait i mean elf-human hybrid) not to mention that *spoiler alert* Brom is eragons father REAL ORIGINAL *rollz eyes* the bloody third book was a waste of my life, So Fucking glad i didn’t buy it, it was so boring that i actually thought up my own ending for the series because the author obviously is having issues with writing a decent piece of literature

quite frankly Harry Potter will always be the better of these series as ar least Harry Potter doesn’t bore me to tears


If you like violence try the book
The Knife Of Never Letting Go by Patrick Ness, its amazing and won’t disappoint

The Fear of Blood Tends to Create the fear for the flesh-SH

Eragon is awful.

So, I guess Harry Potter.

Harry Pothead.

COLOR ME!

Silent Pyramid wrote:

Ulquiorra Schiffer wrote: i think eragon is better cause its with more violence.And dont get me wrong ive read all 7 harry potter books they are my 3rd favorite sereis.but eragon is over all better

The inheritence trilogy opps my bad “Cycle” is a joke, the author can’t write good shit, Eragon was good, but the other books were painful to get throught and his constant descriptions of the bloody elf girl was pointless throughout the books, we get that the author wants sex with a real girl but gawd its annoying, and the twist in eldest were eragon is an elf is laughable (wait i mean elf-human hybrid) not to mention that *spoiler alert* Brom is eragons father REAL ORIGINAL *rollz eyes* the bloody third book was a waste of my life, So Fucking glad i didn’t buy it, it was so boring that i actually thought up my own ending for the series because the author obviously is having issues with writing a decent piece of literature

quite frankly Harry Potter will always be the better of these series as ar least Harry Potter doesn’t bore me to tears


If you like violence try the book
The Knife Of Never Letting Go by Patrick Ness, its amazing and won’t disappoint

I’ll look up on that book.

harry potter has good movies i just dont watch them but i think eragon is better than harry cause i like the action and the dragon was pretty cool in harry i dont like the wizards in there extremely short shorts

Astro Boy X wrote: Gplex y the hell do u have the right to make fun of our religon

Be Nice,and Click. Thanks Tyreaus Dreacon
for the sig

Geass wrote:

slipknot_666_ wrote: i dont like nither.
i think they both suck

learn not to revive threads old threads.Read the first 100 pages before you judge a book while you’re at it.

i have read at least 100 pages before i got bored and went to play pc

Silent Pyramid wrote:

Ulquiorra Schiffer wrote: i think eragon is better cause its with more violence.And dont get me wrong ive read all 7 harry potter books they are my 3rd favorite sereis.but eragon is over all better

The inheritence trilogy opps my bad “Cycle” is a joke, the author can’t write good shit, Eragon was good, but the other books were painful to get throught and his constant descriptions of the bloody elf girl was pointless throughout the books, we get that the author wants sex with a real girl but gawd its annoying, and the twist in eldest were eragon is an elf is laughable (wait i mean elf-human hybrid) not to mention that *spoiler alert* Brom is eragons father REAL ORIGINAL *rollz eyes* the bloody third book was a waste of my life, So Fucking glad i didn’t buy it, it was so boring that i actually thought up my own ending for the series because the author obviously is having issues with writing a decent piece of literature

quite frankly Harry Potter will always be the better of these series as ar least Harry Potter doesn’t bore me to tears


If you like violence try the book
The Knife Of Never Letting Go by Patrick Ness, its amazing and won’t disappoint

Thanks ill be sure to look it up.

I still think Eragon is better than Harry Potter.