X-Play is sadly based towards the 360, I mean a huge 6 hour countdown event for Halo 3? Just plain retarded, it is a very great game but not a god there are much more innovative titles out there.
Bioshock was innovative for being a first person action RPG but it has not much for replay aside from 2 goes, being good or evil then that is it, downloads only add a few more minutes of gameplay.
What happened to Mario Galaxy? I mean it has got to be one of the biggest titles this year yet they just brushed it off like it was nothing. Oh do not even mention Metroid Prime 3, they gave it a 4 out of 5 just because they had trouble trying to control it, yeah still a good score but just because they had trouble controlling it was no reason to dock it a point, I mean the other gestures in that game for casting the grapple beam or pulling switches was easy and not even a gimmick it just added a realistic feel to it. next aiming was great but just because they fail to realize the other control options is no reason to make it an ignored title of the year, yet it has been doing very well, I think G4 is sadly another game critic place that is still not giving the wii the credit is deserves for making new gameplay experiences.
Xplay is a jerk. They called Sunshine the worst 3d Mario of all time.
They said it had crappy graphics (NO), unpolished controls (HECK NO), and nothing new about it. (WTF EXPLAIN FLUDD THEN!!)