Unsung_Hero wrote:
Not to sound like a Dick, but how many of you vote for a sig because it is animated as opposed to still.
fair question and I am not judging your right to chose whichever entry you like.
Oh and this question relates to all previous SOTW too.
So basically, how much of your vote is swayed by animation?
Are you implying that my winter signature was bad?
Not at all, but looking back, There seemed to be a lot of plain Un-animated ones, however since people are submitting animated ones, the trend seems to be that The animated one wins over all other entries.
I wonder is it fair to allow animated signatures into the competition as it seems to be the trend that the animated sig wins, no matter what the competition.
I repeat, I think you’re winter signature was a deserving win, but barely. I would have been torn between yours and 226’s sig.
I also think that some people may be voting for their friends as opposed to which one looks better or appeals to them the most.
Cardice13’s signature entry comes to mind. It won above all other entries and I feel that was a rigged round as there were many more superior entries in my own mind that should have won.
Unsung_Hero wrote:
Not to sound like a Dick, but how many of you vote for a sig because it is animated as opposed to still.
fair question and I am not judging your right to chose whichever entry you like.
Oh and this question relates to all previous SOTW too.
So basically, how much of your vote is swayed by animation?
Are you implying that my winter signature was bad?
Not at all, but looking back, There seemed to be a lot of plain Un-animated ones, however since people are submitting animated ones, the trend seems to be that The animated one wins over all other entries.
I wonder is it fair to allow animated signatures into the competition as it seems to be the trend that the animated sig wins, no matter what the competition.
I repeat, I think you’re winter signature was a deserving win, but barely. I would have been torn between yours and 226’s sig.
I also think that some people may be voting for their friends as opposed to which one looks better or appeals to them the most.
Cardice13’s signature entry comes to mind. It won above all other entries and I feel that was a rigged round as there were many more superior entries in my own mind that should have won.
Well in the winter one, not only did you suggest Cid animate it, but personally I thought it was the best entry.
I don’t know about others but I’m not particularly close to anyone who enters the sig competitions. I vote for what appeals to me and/or what is graphically the best. For some people humour may be what appeals to them (PS3 and Cardice’s for example).
Forums Index >
Contests/Trivia 
