I do not want any assumptions not backed with facts. Don’t say “Broly wins because he’s cool." I want facts, and proof. and since none of you have 40K knowledge, I’ll just fill you in on the IGEOM, and since I’m a lazy Jackass I’ll just re-post the IGEOM’s powers from the IGEOM vs. Beyonder thread. You all know who Broly is.
The Immortal God Emperor of Mankind is the 20,000 year old leader of the Imperium of man. He is an ultra-powerful psyker, meaning he has telepathy and other mental powers. Here is a rough scale of psyker classes:
Normal: Can hurl lightning, strip soul, and do mind tricks.
High: can send armies crazy, slag tanks.
Very high: can send planets crazy, snap 500 foot tall mechs in half with a wave of his hand.
high times roughly 100: IGEOM.
At his weakest point, he held off four chaos gods, with his blood turned to poison, an arm and an eye missing, and fighting his favored son, who could flay people by glancing at them. He killed his son with a supernova level blast, and despite being wounded fatally he was placed in a life support device. He keeps reality whole with his mind, and guides all imperial ships through the warp. He has stopped time in the entire galaxy, and I think there are cases of him destroying planets. As we are talking about pre-golden chair version (otherwise this is completely unfair) he wore sacred golden armor, and he wielded a lightning claw on his left hand (a glove with three blades, with an electrical/power field around them, kind of like a lightsaber), and he had a force sword, meaning he could channel his power through it. This would make a tap from him roughly equal to getting hit by a star. They never actually set a limit on his power either, but i assume that he could rip apart reality with his mind. He also could potentially change someone’s destiny, as he controls the warp. where fates are written.
Her has a force weapon. Now think of it this way: it’s a freaking blazing sword. He can channel all his psychic power into a strike. Now, for a guy who could destroy a galaxy on a whim, using his mind, how much damage would the sword do if it was swung by him? As far as I heard, Broly was destroyed when hurled into the sun. Now imagine a galaxy buster focused into the blade of a sword hitting him. Besides, I do not believe Broly is immune to having his soul flayed or getting mindraped.
You can find them at Dicehead Games & Comics. We have one over in Cleveland, TN, not far from where I live in. And check the first page. Warhammer is on it.