Remember me
[Forgot password?] [Register]
The Lounge Forums

Muggles VS Harry Potter Wizards in a giant war around the world

[Reply] #1
11-03-2009 01:52 PM
Joined: 11-03-2009
Posts: 14
offline
Darth Remus
Wannabe
Rep: 1

Who Do you think would win? the muggles? or wizards?
the muggles have numbers, nukes, machine guns and many other ways to reek destruction, Wizards have spells but are limited and i doubt they would be able to stop a nuke...

Muggles VS Harry Potter Wizards in a giant war around the world

Muggles********************************** 67%
(votes so far 14)


Wizards******** 14%
(votes so far 3)


Neither, they would spend hundreds of years fighting without any outcome...********** 19%
(votes so far 4)


Only registered users may vote.

[Reply] #2
11-03-2009 03:40 PM
Joined: 09-18-2009
Posts: 3,994
offline
Captain America
Captain America
UBER 1337 Poster
Rep: 81

Muggles ftw.


__________________

Credit for the sigs goes to Slayer/CoolTaff12:


[Reply] #3
11-03-2009 04:25 PM
Joined: 11-03-2009
Posts: 14
offline
Darth Remus
Wannabe
Rep: 1

if the muggles attacked with nukes, it would take all of the wiz. power to stop one and the muggles could blow the fuck out of them while they are distracted...

[Reply] #4
11-03-2009 04:32 PM
Joined: 02-06-2009
Posts: 527
offline
HellRider
HellRider
Regular
Rep: 7

I think Rowling once admitted that one of the reasons why wizards are hiding is that they are afraid of possiblity of a war with muggles, because they would lose it for sure.

[Reply] #5
11-03-2009 05:51 PM
Joined: 04-30-2007
Posts: 26,637
offline
Red_Calibur9
Red_Calibur9
So am I an admin or what?
Rep: 142

Nukes? Would that not also cause Muggle casualties?


__________________

[Reply] #6
11-03-2009 10:19 PM
Joined: 05-20-2009
Posts: 522
offline
Faust
Regular
Rep: 15

I’m more interested in what you imagine they are going to nuke? Hogwarts where no electronic works and that for any muggler looks like a old ruined castle with a “no trespassing” sign?

What one needs to understand about the War that would take place in the Harry Potter Universe, is that the Wizards isn’t going to line up on a long line and then walk towards the mugglers army, this isn’t a first world war scenario.

They will (providing the Deatheaters is involved and even if they isn’t I think they still would) fight dirty. The Wizards can with their magic become more lethal then any terrororganisation, they can strike anywhere at any time when they wishes it, forget about finding out anything, one day the plane just crashes, the power keeps going out, trains gets derailed, The armies weapons keeps disappearing.

No one will be safe, the leading politicians and generals will be either replaced ore simply put under the Imperius Curse. USA is right now showing exactly how difficult this kind of battle will be, fighting a foe that can strike anywhere and looks exactly like the civilian population (and a small bonus for the Wizards) and that can disappear at any time they want to and teleport themselves to another part of the globe.

Who are we going to nuke and attack? Everyone?

[Reply] #7
11-19-2010 04:27 AM
11212343421A
Guest

If wizards began to attack muggles, muggles would easily win but at high costs. Nuke the whole world, wizards can not survive nuclear fallout

[Reply] #8
11-19-2010 05:13 AM
Joined: 09-23-2009
Posts: 6,463
offline
FallenSanity
FallenSanity
Man, Feels Bad
Rep: 59

Avada Kadavra here,
Teleport,
Avada Kadavra there,
and vua-la, every world leader is dead.

[Reply] #9
11-19-2010 10:32 AM
Joined: 09-16-2010
Posts: 5,153
offline
Ussj Future Trunks
Ussj Future Trunks
Addict (beyond 1337)
Rep: 79

muggles godstomp. their nukes are basically one big city busting avada kedavra.

[Reply] #10
11-19-2010 10:35 AM
Joined: 10-15-2009
Posts: 46,040
offline
Slade Robison
Slade Robison
Rapping like no tomorrow
Rep: 241

Wizards curbstomp.


__________________

Hurricane wrote: There’s always somebody, who really wants to make you fall
But you can rise above, rise above it all
Don’t listen to the lies, that try to make you feel so small
Cause you’re a hurricane, and you’re riding through the storm
Riding through the storm.

[Reply] #11
11-19-2010 10:43 AM
Joined: 12-14-2009
Posts: 6,618
offline
Fabulous Falsey
Fabulous Falsey
i aint no addict
Rep: 116

Has it ever been mentioned in Harry Potter that Muggles have nukes? Nope? Than you can’t use it in this debate to there being no cannon material that they possess any.


Remember, Harry Potter vese is a alternative to ours, so you can’t say that muggles have nukes for certein just because we do IRL.


__________________

Probable KoS wrote: Thatís come down as in the bad phase of the high, and coke as in coke meth.

[Reply] #12
11-19-2010 10:43 AM
Joined: 08-22-2006
Posts: 35,875
offline
Nerevar
Nerevar
Savior Gone Chaotic
Rep: 113

Muggles fucking rape. We’re taking billions against, what? Thousands? Tens of thousands? Even with millions they’re be massively outnumbered. The children wizards would all die first, then the normal adult wizards because they don’t know proper combatant spells. Only the teachers and Ministry would stand any chance, and even then they would just get mowed down. They couldn’t show their face without being shot or beaten to death.

So what if some wizard avada kedavra’d some world leaders? That wouldn’t halt or even slow down the war.

FalseMemorySyndrome wrote: Has it ever been mentioned in Harry Potter that Muggles have nukes? Nope? Than you can’t use it in this debate to there being no cannon material that they possess any.


Remember, Harry Potter vese is a alternative to ours, so you can’t say that muggles have nukes for certein just because we do IRL.



That’s really bad logic dude. =/


__________________

Edited 11-19-2010 10:44 AM by Nerevar
[Reply] #13
11-19-2010 10:45 AM
Joined: 12-14-2009
Posts: 6,618
offline
Fabulous Falsey
Fabulous Falsey
i aint no addict
Rep: 116

It’s typical verse cannon.

Nothing less and nothing more.


__________________

Probable KoS wrote: Thatís come down as in the bad phase of the high, and coke as in coke meth.

[Reply] #14
11-19-2010 10:47 AM
Joined: 08-22-2006
Posts: 35,875
offline
Nerevar
Nerevar
Savior Gone Chaotic
Rep: 113

FalseMemorySyndrome wrote: It’s typical verse cannon.

Nothing less and nothing more.



Wut

Please stop posting. It hurts.


__________________

[Reply] #15
11-19-2010 10:48 AM
Joined: 12-10-2009
Posts: 6,815
offline
Karasu
Karasu
Gamer-pro
Rep: 93

The harry potter world only has one differnce from ours. There are wizerads and stuff. It has military it has a president it has a police force and it has multibal humans. Humans made nukes so they can make nukes there too. They made guns they can make guns there too. We already know they have guns because they have cars. Guns were before cars, so they have to have them. Even if it’s old guns they still have them.


__________________

[Reply] #16
11-19-2010 10:49 AM
Joined: 09-23-2009
Posts: 6,463
offline
FallenSanity
FallenSanity
Man, Feels Bad
Rep: 59

I’m pretty sure killing the President, Queen, etc, would at least slow down... Hmm, everything?

Also, you seem to be forgetting the epic Tom Riddle, and that the rat guy was able to kill, I think, one hundred muggles in the blink of an eye. He was far from a good wizard.

[Reply] #17
11-19-2010 10:54 AM
Joined: 08-22-2006
Posts: 35,875
offline
Nerevar
Nerevar
Savior Gone Chaotic
Rep: 113

FallenSanity wrote: I’m pretty sure killing the President, Queen, etc, would at least slow down... Hmm, everything?

Also, you seem to be forgetting the epic Tom Riddle, and that the rat guy was able to kill, I think, one hundred muggles in the blink of an eye. He was far from a good wizard.



In a global war? Not a chance. The US presidency, for instance, has over 20 people in line if the leader dies. Not to mention Congress could function without a leader in times of crisis... and I think a band of killer wizards would be considered one.

Even without any government the 'people' would still fight. Killing the leader isn’t going to stop the troops from advancing or the hillbillies from grabbin them shotgunz.


__________________

[Reply] #18
11-19-2010 10:54 AM
Joined: 12-14-2009
Posts: 6,618
offline
Fabulous Falsey
Fabulous Falsey
i aint no addict
Rep: 116

FallenSanity wrote: I’m pretty sure killing the President, Queen, etc, would at least slow down... Hmm, everything?

Also, you seem to be forgetting the epic Tom Riddle, and that the rat guy was able to kill, I think, one hundred muggles in the blink of an eye. He was far from a good wizard.

I think it was a dozen or so. But yeah, if you take out the world leaders and the people in charge of coderating a groups defense you’ve practicly one.


__________________

Probable KoS wrote: Thatís come down as in the bad phase of the high, and coke as in coke meth.

[Reply] #19
11-19-2010 10:56 AM
Joined: 09-23-2009
Posts: 6,463
offline
FallenSanity
FallenSanity
Man, Feels Bad
Rep: 59

Nerevar wrote:

FallenSanity wrote: I’m pretty sure killing the President, Queen, etc, would at least slow down... Hmm, everything?

Also, you seem to be forgetting the epic Tom Riddle, and that the rat guy was able to kill, I think, one hundred muggles in the blink of an eye. He was far from a good wizard.



In a global war? Not a chance. The US presidency, for instance, has over 20 people in line if the leader dies. Not to mention Congress could function without a leader in times of crisis... and I think a band of killer wizards would be considered one.

Even without any government the 'people' would still fight. Killing the leader isn’t going to stop the troops from advancing or the hillbillies from grabbin them shotgunz.



Okay, so a simple eradication of all of the possible world leaders.
Remember, certain wizards can 'teleport'.

[Reply] #20
11-19-2010 10:59 AM
Joined: 08-22-2006
Posts: 35,875
offline
Nerevar
Nerevar
Savior Gone Chaotic
Rep: 113

FallenSanity wrote:

Nerevar wrote:

FallenSanity wrote: I’m pretty sure killing the President, Queen, etc, would at least slow down... Hmm, everything?

Also, you seem to be forgetting the epic Tom Riddle, and that the rat guy was able to kill, I think, one hundred muggles in the blink of an eye. He was far from a good wizard.



In a global war? Not a chance. The US presidency, for instance, has over 20 people in line if the leader dies. Not to mention Congress could function without a leader in times of crisis... and I think a band of killer wizards would be considered one.

Even without any government the 'people' would still fight. Killing the leader isn’t going to stop the troops from advancing or the hillbillies from grabbin them shotgunz.



Okay, so a simple eradication of all of the possible world leaders.
Remember, certain wizards can 'teleport'.



The only thing that would do is maybe restrict access to nuclear weapons. Big whoop.


__________________

New Reply
Name (guest):

For faster posting and no restrictions: [Login] [Register]

Message:
Type the characters you see in the picture:
 
[More Options] [New Topic]
The Lounge Forums ( lounge.moviecodec.com ) ©Silicon.dk ApS 2012 - Privacy Policy - Disclaimer - FAQ - Contact
MVC Network: MovieCodec Forums/Downloads -The Lounge Forums