Remember me
[Forgot password?] [Register]
The Lounge Forums

Who is stronger: Sonic or Shadow?

#1
10-09-2011 02:44 PM
Weskerly
Guest

Taking the canon into account, I guess Sonic?

#2
10-09-2011 03:06 PM
Asmodeus
Guest

Sonic defeated Silver, Shadow stalemated Silver.

Not hard.

#3
10-09-2011 03:07 PM
Joined: 09-21-2011
Posts: 2,592
offline
D Vance
D Vance
UBER 1337 Poster
Rep: 52

Sonic

but Shadow is more badass


__________________

Mau5 wrote: So you just admitted you’re gay, just not as gay as I am...

Good job dude.

#4
10-09-2011 03:18 PM
Joined: 06-04-2011
Posts: 4,603
offline
Kuroka
Kuroka
UBER 1337 Poster
Rep: 105

sonic


__________________

#5
10-09-2011 03:37 PM
Joined: 04-24-2010
Posts: 5,567
offline
Time and Space
Time and Space
I hope senpai will notice me!
Rep: 117

Sonic.


__________________


It’s like the evangelion of...nevermind.

#6
10-09-2011 03:47 PM
Joined: 09-08-2011
Posts: 14,510
offline
Omniwhatever
Omniwhatever
Lightning God
Rep: 135

In the game canon I think it goes like this.

I think in an IC fight Shadow is a bit(Not by much) ahead considering his willingness to use Chaos Powers more, and he has more.

Bloodlusted I’d say it’s either a stalemate or Sonic is slightly ahead.

I’d say they’re definitely very, very close though.

Also, wasn’t it said at one point Shadow would eventually defeat Sonic in a fight but Sonic would eventually defeat Shadow in a race? I think this was said in Sonic Chronicles though, which I’m not sure if it’s canon.


__________________



~Dark Necter~ Embodiment of Chaos

#7
10-09-2011 05:46 PM
Joined: 11-30-2010
Posts: 34,319
offline
Wolfey
Wolfey
As I love you
Rep: 203

Omniwhatever wrote: Also, wasn’t it said at one point Shadow would eventually defeat Sonic in a fight but Sonic would eventually defeat Shadow in a race? I think this was said in Sonic Chronicles though, which I’m not sure if it’s canon.



Shadow did say that in Sonic Chronicles: The Dark Brotherhood.

However, that is somewhat of a spinoff game. It’s the only game in the franchise not made by Sonic Team, It was made by BioWare. So I wouldn’t take BioWare’s opinion very seriously on this matter.

IC I think Shadow might have an edge. Intent to defeat: Sonic definitely wins. He even defeated Silver, whom Shadow could only stalemate.

Plus, Sega seems to consider Sonic The true Ultimate Lifeform, so I’ll go with Sonic here.


__________________

Illusive Trickster wrote: When have you ever let me down?
<3

Edited 10-09-2011 05:47 PM by Wolfey
#8
10-09-2011 05:47 PM
Joined: 10-09-2011
Posts: 3
offline
The Fallen Troll
The Fallen Troll
Entree
Rep: 0

shadow. hes a winner


__________________

#9
10-09-2011 05:51 PM
Joined: 09-09-2011
Posts: 880
offline
K3
K3
Regular
Rep: 20

*puts bais-ness aside*Well....id have to say sonic...but hes not that far ahead its not like a HUGE gap but if they did fight taking everything into account everything from Archie,Games,and Anime...then the best they could hope for would be a stalemate...with sonic leading...as long as the whole prophecywontlethimloseaseriousbattle thing isnt present shocked

#10
10-09-2011 05:55 PM
Joined: 09-08-2011
Posts: 14,510
offline
Omniwhatever
Omniwhatever
Lightning God
Rep: 135

Wolfenstein wrote:

Omniwhatever wrote: Also, wasn’t it said at one point Shadow would eventually defeat Sonic in a fight but Sonic would eventually defeat Shadow in a race? I think this was said in Sonic Chronicles though, which I’m not sure if it’s canon.



Shadow did say that in Sonic Chronicles: The Dark Brotherhood.

However, that is somewhat of a spinoff game. It’s the only game in the franchise not made by Sonic Team, It was made by BioWare. So I wouldn’t take BioWare’s opinion very seriously on this matter.

IC I think Shadow might have an edge. Intent to defeat: Sonic definitely wins. He even defeated Silver, whom Shadow could only stalemate.

Plus, Sega seems to consider Sonic The true Ultimate Lifeform, so I’ll go with Sonic here.



Well, it was a stalemate until Shadow decided to Chaos control, then he swiftly roundhouse kicked Silver and looked like it hurt.

That and are we sure Sonic’s story is the canon fight? In Silver’s he beats Sonic, yet in Sonic’s he beats Silver.


__________________



~Dark Necter~ Embodiment of Chaos

Edited 10-09-2011 05:56 PM by Omniwhatever
#11
10-09-2011 05:58 PM
Joined: 11-30-2010
Posts: 34,319
offline
Wolfey
Wolfey
As I love you
Rep: 203

Omniwhatever wrote: Well, it was a stalemate until Shadow decided to Chaos control, then he swiftly roundhouse kicked Silver and looked like it hurt.



Yea. But that’s cheating.

Dohohohohoho.

Anyway, I believe Sonic would eventually win if they fought all out. They are by no means far from each other since most of their encounters end in stalemates and their speed is somewhat even.

But because Shadow has said he thinks Sonic is the Ultimate Lifeform, and because Shadow lost power in the end of SAB2 and Sonic did not, I’m going with Sonic.


__________________

Illusive Trickster wrote: When have you ever let me down?
<3

#12
10-09-2011 06:04 PM
Joined: 09-08-2011
Posts: 14,510
offline
Omniwhatever
Omniwhatever
Lightning God
Rep: 135

Wolfenstein wrote:

Omniwhatever wrote: Well, it was a stalemate until Shadow decided to Chaos control, then he swiftly roundhouse kicked Silver and looked like it hurt.



Yea. But that’s cheating.

Dohohohohoho.

Anyway, I believe Sonic would eventually win if they fought all out. They are by no means far from each other since most of their encounters end in stalemates and their speed is somewhat even.

But because Shadow has said he thinks Sonic is the Ultimate Lifeform, and because Shadow lost power in the end of SAB2 and Sonic did not, I’m going with Sonic.



Lol true, timestop/timeslow is definitely hax hehe. Shadow does seem to love it though.

To be fair, that was the first time Shadow went Super. Sonic had done it a lot. In later games when Shadow went Super he didn’t seem to have the same problem keeping power.

But yeah if they fought all out and both say had a Chaos Emerald. It would be INCREDIBLY close, but Sonic might be able to pull off a very close win.


__________________



~Dark Necter~ Embodiment of Chaos

#13
10-09-2011 06:10 PM
Joined: 11-30-2010
Posts: 34,319
offline
Wolfey
Wolfey
As I love you
Rep: 203

What about in things other than the games?

I haven’t seen Sonic X but I think they are equal there too.

Sonic Prime would probably defeat Shadow Prime in a fight.


__________________

Illusive Trickster wrote: When have you ever let me down?
<3

#14
10-09-2011 06:12 PM
Joined: 08-24-2011
Posts: 6,404
offline
King Kazuma
King Kazuma
[Good Loser]
Rep: 83

Goku


__________________

#15
10-09-2011 06:14 PM
Joined: 09-08-2011
Posts: 14,510
offline
Omniwhatever
Omniwhatever
Lightning God
Rep: 135

Wolfenstein wrote: What about in things other than the games?

I haven’t seen Sonic X but I think they are equal there too.

Sonic Prime would probably defeat Shadow Prime in a fight.



Anime Shadow wtf stomped the Sonic team. Rather easily lol. Anime Shadow is above anime Sonic. Not by a huge margin, but it is noticeable.

Archie on the otherhand, yeah. Sonic Prime would win, it would still be a relatively close fight, but Sonic Prime still does have much more hax.


__________________



~Dark Necter~ Embodiment of Chaos

Edited 10-09-2011 06:14 PM by Omniwhatever
#16
10-09-2011 06:20 PM
Joined: 11-30-2010
Posts: 34,319
offline
Wolfey
Wolfey
As I love you
Rep: 203

Omniwhatever wrote: Anime Shadow wtf stomped the Sonic team. Rather easily lol. Anime Shadow is above anime Sonic. Not by a huge margin, but it is noticeable.



Really? It must have been his debut fight then. Because I heard they were pretty even in Sonic X.


__________________

Illusive Trickster wrote: When have you ever let me down?
<3

#17
10-09-2011 06:32 PM
Joined: 09-08-2011
Posts: 14,510
offline
Omniwhatever
Omniwhatever
Lightning God
Rep: 135

Wolfenstein wrote:

Omniwhatever wrote: Anime Shadow wtf stomped the Sonic team. Rather easily lol. Anime Shadow is above anime Sonic. Not by a huge margin, but it is noticeable.



Really? It must have been his debut fight then. Because I heard they were pretty even in Sonic X.



Actually it was in season 3 where he got ridiculously overpowered.

Shadow had gotten on board the good teams ship, two-shot Sonic with a Chaos Spear(These REALLY hurt) and Spin dash.

One Shot Knuckles.

And one shot the X-Tornado.

He was also blowing up Meterex ships(Not the small ones) left and right, which Sonic had some trouble with.


__________________



~Dark Necter~ Embodiment of Chaos

#18
10-09-2011 06:41 PM
Joined: 11-30-2010
Posts: 34,319
offline
Wolfey
Wolfey
As I love you
Rep: 203

So was that a legit fight or more of a sneak attack?

What about the other times they fought?

Edit: Wait...If Sonic Team created the Sonic X anime...does that mean It’s canon to the games? Is Chris canon?


__________________

Illusive Trickster wrote: When have you ever let me down?
<3

Edited 10-09-2011 06:45 PM by Wolfey
#19
10-09-2011 06:48 PM
Joined: 09-08-2011
Posts: 14,510
offline
Omniwhatever
Omniwhatever
Lightning God
Rep: 135

Wolfenstein wrote: So was that a legit fight or more of a sneak attack?

What about the other times they fought?



Actually it was a legit fight. Shadow did get the first hit with a Chaos Spear on Sonic since Sonic had to push Chris(Got I hate him) out of the way. Past that it was a legit fight that ended quickly.

The other fights in base form I believe there was only one.

In it Shadow had the advantage until Sonic got a ring. Then the playing field was a bit leveled.

Oh no, Sonic X is not canon to the games. It has it’s own canon, and it’s not part of the games. It has tie ins though.


__________________



~Dark Necter~ Embodiment of Chaos

Edited 10-09-2011 06:49 PM by Omniwhatever
#20
10-09-2011 07:06 PM
Joined: 11-30-2010
Posts: 34,319
offline
Wolfey
Wolfey
As I love you
Rep: 203

Omniwhatever wrote: Actually it was a legit fight. Shadow did get the first hit with a Chaos Spear on Sonic since Sonic had to push Chris(Got I hate him) out of the way. Past that it was a legit fight that ended quickly.



Ah, I assumed It was something like that.

Still, I’m not so sure that’s proof of Shadow’s superiority in the anime. He did get a “sneak attack” in.

Weren’t their Super form fights pretty much even?

Omniwhatever wrote: The other fights in base form I believe there was only one.

In it Shadow had the advantage until Sonic got a ring. Then the playing field was a bit leveled.



Do you know what episode was that?

Just by browsing you-tube, I see they had alot of fights in Sonic X.

Omniwhatever wrote: Oh no, Sonic X is not canon to the games. It has itís own canon, and itís not part of the games. It has tie ins though.



Well, but It was still created by Sonic Team? Is It like Sonic X Sonic is a different Sonic from Game Sonic or something?


__________________

Illusive Trickster wrote: When have you ever let me down?
<3

The Lounge Forums ( lounge.moviecodec.com ) ©Silicon.dk ApS 2012 - Privacy Policy - Disclaimer - FAQ - Contact
MVC Network: MovieCodec Forums/Downloads -The Lounge Forums